By akademiotoelektronik, 29/06/2022
What are the best drones?Comparison 2022 Return Home Clubic
Stéphane Paputspecialist drones06 November 2021 at 3:500 p.m.Thanks to the miniaturization and the constant drop in prices, drones democratize and open to an ever wider audience.But their operation and their performance levels can remain complex to understand for the uninitiated.
Choice of editorial 679,20 €Lire le test9Dji Mavic Air 2
Choice of editorial
679,20 €Lire le test9Lire le test9679,20 € Value for money399 €Lire le test8Dji Mavic Mini
Value for money
399 €Lire le test8Lire le test8 399 € Top top1199 €Lire le test9Dji Mavic 2 Pro
Top top
1199 €Lire le test9Lire le test9 1199 €Given the many technical specificities, finding the best drone to meet your needs is a delicate process to approach.The technology evolving very quickly, a model can become obsolete and see its price lose all legitimacy, without perceptible signs on the communications supports of manufacturers.
In this comparison, we have therefore tried to summarize the strengths and weaknesses of the most popular drones of the moment, and to assign them a level of use.Representing the current market, the selection is largely dominated by DJI and rather generally public oriented, but contains some models of other brands and more advanced uses.
1. Dji Mavic Air
Voir le prixLire le test 7DJI Mavic AirUn bon compromisLe meilleur des 2 mondes ?Despite some concerns of ergonomics and compatibility, the Mavic Air shone on several facets, especially on its autonomous flight capacities.The quality of the camera is very good, but will unfortunately not meet all levels of requirement.We regret the avalanche of dysfunctions on the test model, which probably lightens the general note of half a point.
Le meilleur des 2 mondes ?Despite some concerns of ergonomics and compatibility, the Mavic Air shone on several facets, especially on its autonomous flight capacities.The quality of the camera is very good, but will unfortunately not meet all levels of requirement.We regret the avalanche of dysfunctions on the test model, which probably lightens the general note of half a point.
Marketed in 2018, the Mavic Air is the first size and weight drone so reduced offering navigation and capture performance equivalent to the large models of older generations.So without competition, he completely revolutionized the market completely.
Halfway between the DJI Spark and the Mavic Pro, it offers an incomparable compromise at the time by taking on a 4K recording, a 3-axis stabilized nacelle and navigation assistance, while retaining minimal size.The standard package gives access to high -end equipment sufficient for a serene grip.
Brilliant but not perfect
In general, maneuverability is remarkable.Very complete, it has the detection and obstacle avoidance function, many smart flight modes such as Activetrack, QuickShots or Smartgesture.All the features tested have shown enough defects.
Unfortunately, it suffers from autonomy and signal quality below what is announced.The Mavic Air takes up a 1/2.3 '' CMOS sensor similar to the pro.Despite some small functional problems, the 12MP photo capture is versatile and of superb quality, supported by a sharpness perhaps a little too pronounced.
In video, the 1080p is impeccable to all cadences, but the slow-motion is unusable.The 4K@30fps is very good with a pronounced dive and an acceptable fluidity.The colors are bright, even a little too saturated.
Dji Mavic Air at the best price
| Fnac | 849,99€ | Voir l'offre |
| Rue Du Commerce marketplace | 998,33€ | Voir l'offre |
| Fnac marketplace | 1004€ | Voir l'offre |
| Darty marketplace | 1018,97€ | Voir l'offre |
| Cdiscount marketplace | 1197,14€ | Voir l'offre |
2. Parrot Anafi
Voir le prixLire le test 8Parrot AnafiCocoricoL'alternative françaiseWithout being a marvel of perfection, the Parrot Anafi was able to review its copy and obtains a very good mention in each subject.The size is minimal and transport, accommodating.We just regret the few design shells.Overall, the Anafi provides very good flight experience.However, remember to customize the navigation settings so that they are adapted to your piloting style and to compensate for the absence of local sensors.The features are complete.The photo and video quality is simply stunning for the size and weight of the device.
L'alternative françaiseWithout being a marvel of perfection, the Parrot Anafi was able to review its copy and obtains a very good mention in each subject.The size is minimal and transport, accommodating.We just regret the few design shells.Overall, the Anafi provides very good flight experience.However, remember to customize the navigation settings so that they are adapted to your piloting style and to compensate for the absence of local sensors.The features are complete.The photo and video quality is simply stunning for the size and weight of the device.
Launched in 2018 with certain unpublished characteristics, such as its vertical 180 ° swivel camera, the Parrot Anafi has everything to please.However, it has a limited success with the general public but continues to be improved by the French manufacturer and declined in several versions, notably with professionals.
After a bebop generation whose performance was mixed, the ANAFI marked a radical change in design and technology.With a featherweight of 320 g and a 4K recording, it opposes the Mavic Air and constitutes an excellent alternative for those favors the quality of the camera to the obstacle detection features.
The Swiss knife
The ANAFI has good control precision and good stabilization, but quickly suffers the winds.Lawygility requires a little training but customizable flight presets will help you find your bearings.You access a complete range of automated flight modes, such as cinehots, smartdronies or Cameraman mode.
During the tests, almost all of the features made a flawless.Thanks to its Sony CMOS 1/2.4 '' sensor of 21MP and its aspherical lens, the Anafi produces an amazing image quality, particularly in RAW.However, it will take post-traitment to eliminate the Fish-Eye effect or to obtain a 16: 9 format.Video recording is sublime, from 1080p@24FPS.
The colors remain natural and the dive is impressive.Apart from a slightly disappointing HDR mode, the capture functions are very convincing.
Parrot Anafi at the best price
Nous n'avons pas trouvé d'offre en stock chez nos partenaires3. YUNEEC MANTIS G
525 € Lire le test 5Yuneec Mantis GHaut de gammeIntéressant mais en promotion
Definitely, Yuneec will find it difficult to distinguish itself with the Mantis range.The manufacturer shows a lot of good will with this G model, providing strong equipment and innovation efforts.The manual flight experience is interesting, even pleasant.But certain automatic flight methods and the voice command still lack too much maturity.The quality of photo and video capture may be enough for leisure use, but will remain passable without post-production.
Intéressant mais en promotionDefinitely, Yuneec will find it difficult to distinguish itself with the Mantis range.The manufacturer shows a lot of good will with this G model, providing strong equipment and innovation efforts.The manual flight experience is interesting, even pleasant.But certain automatic flight methods and the voice command still lack too much maturity.The quality of photo and video capture may be enough for leisure use, but will remain passable without post-production.
With the Mantis G, Yuneec renews its attempt to break through in the ultraportable leisure category.The specialist in professional drones offers us a voice control system here, and a dazzling sports fashion.
Like the preceding Q model, this drone is positioned as a high -end in view of the price, the packaging and the level of equipment provided.But although it was released in 2019, it shows a considerable technological delay in the face of an Anafi or a Mavic Air.
Perceptible innovation efforts
Despite certain difficulties, the Mantis G provides acceptable flight experience after a few hours of training and adequate configuration.With powerful accelerations, sport mode is particularly spectacular.Apart from a precise tracking system, there are few automated flight modes, however and remain to be developed.
Flagship function of the drone, the Voice-Control indeed has its little interest and allows it to stand out from its competitors.The CMOS 1/3.06 '' sensor from 13MP from the Mantis G provides correct quality photos but far from reaching excellence.For this, reprocessing will be necessary.Ditto for the video, which will be usable from 2.7K but which will require a 4K correction.
The colors and the sharpness are good but the stabilization will unfortunately leave something to be desired.
YUNEEC MANTIS G at the best price
| Fnac marketplace | 525€ | Voir l'offre |
| Amazon | 564,22€ | Voir l'offre |
| Cdiscount marketplace | 574,64€ | Voir l'offre |
| Rue Du Commerce marketplace | 619,13€ | Voir l'offre |
| Darty marketplace | 628,13€ | Voir l'offre |
| Cdiscount marketplace | 651,40€ | Voir l'offre |
4. Dji Mavic Air 2
679,20 € Lire le test 9Dji Mavic Air 2Choice of editorialLe meilleur choix (pour nous)Without a real point of weakness, we are won over by the high quality of the equipment and its audiovisual production capacities.The new profile of the RC and the minimalist clutter of the drone fills all expectations.Manual navigation and automated captures can delight initiates, and suit all beginners.We are completely seduced by the power of the camera, which at the base produces only a meager 12MP.However, we regret not having the choice of HDR in panorama or smartphoto, and the interface would need to be a little more explicit at times.Despite excellent autonomy, count 1:30 for a complete recharge.To fully appreciate your drone outings, opt immediately for a Bundle Fly More, which offers a very attractive price considering additional equipment.
Le meilleur choix (pour nous)Without a real point of weakness, we are won over by the high quality of the equipment and its audiovisual production capacities.The new profile of the RC and the minimalist clutter of the drone fills all expectations.Manual navigation and automated captures can delight initiates, and suit all beginners.We are completely seduced by the power of the camera, which at the base produces only a meager 12MP.However, we regret not having the choice of HDR in panorama or smartphoto, and the interface would need to be a little more explicit at times.Despite excellent autonomy, count 1:30 for a complete recharge.To fully appreciate your drone outings, opt immediately for a Bundle Fly More, which offers a very attractive price considering additional equipment.
Lancé au printemps 2020, en pleine crise sanitaire, le Dji Mavic Air 2 a pourtant reçu un accueil plus que chaleureux, marqué notamment par l'arrivé d'un capteur optique sans équivalent sur un drone et de nouvelles fonctionnalités.
Located between a shattering Mavic Mini and a professional MAVIC 2, the Mavic Air 2 crushes all competition existing on the high -end leisure drone market.
After the austerity of its interface, the basic package promises an unforgettable experience, in particular thanks to a radical change in radio control.
The almost ideal companion
Supported by the formidable APAS piloting assistance and its obstacle detection system, maneuverability forgives any lack of training.Numerous flight features and automated DJI captures are renewed, such as Activetrack 3.0, and other transplanted from the Pro range, such as the SPOTLIGHT 2.0.
The hyperlapse is highly highlighted on this model, with 4 capture modes from intelligent flight modes, such as Waypoint, but which will unfortunately not be available for video.
With its 1/2 inch CMOS sensor Quad Bayer, the camera makes images of very good quality in 12MP.The High Resolution 48MP mode is breathtaking, with rich colors and an upper dive.Video capture only suffers from very little defects and offers advanced functions, such as H.265, and highly anticipated resolutions such as 4K@60FPS or 1080p@240FPS.
Dji Mavic Air 2 au meilleur prix
| Macway | 679,20€ | Voir l'offre |
| Rue Du Commerce marketplace | 814,99€ | Voir l'offre |
| Amazon | 835€ | Voir l'offre |
| Fnac marketplace | 835€ | Voir l'offre |
| Cdiscount marketplace | 847,78€ | Voir l'offre |
| Boulanger | 849€ | Voir l'offre |
| Cdiscount | 849€ | Voir l'offre |
| Cdiscount | 849€ | Voir l'offre |
| Darty | 849€ | Voir l'offre |
| Fnac | 849,99€ | Voir l'offre |
| Darty marketplace | 917,86€ | Voir l'offre |
5. Dji Phantom 4 Pro V2 Plus
2179,99 € Lire le test 8DJI Phantom 4 Pro V2 PlusToujours excellentUn excellent packageUsing the main characteristics of the first version, the Phantom 4 Pro V2.0 always offers an excellent package, both in terms of navigation performance, as well as photographic equipment, despite the few ergonomics problems of the interface.The latest technological additions rejuvenate the model and will be able to delight demanding drone pilots.
Un excellent packageUsing the main characteristics of the first version, the Phantom 4 Pro V2.0 always offers an excellent package, both in terms of navigation performance, as well as photographic equipment, despite the few ergonomics problems of the interface.The latest technological additions rejuvenate the model and will be able to delight demanding drone pilots.
By refreshing their flagship model of 2016, DJI has somewhat disappointed aficionados of the range.The Phantom 4 Pro V2 retains a proven camera, however, and improves its transmission and positioning system.
Renewed, the 2018 model is more successful and offers a capture similar to Mavic 2 Pro.Weight and size are much more substantial.The version Plus includes a radio control with a screen and an OS integrated into criticism, and only include one battery.
Aging but reliable
Concentrated on navigation, this V2 brings new sensors, the Ocusync system and new ESCS.The controls are reactive and precise, and stabilization is effective, despite perhaps a little long braking.Not to mention perfection, driving assistance is efficient especially to detect obstacles.You access the first versions of Activetrack and DJI smart flight modes, all present and functional, but not the QuickShots.
The camera is equipped with a large CMOS 1 '' 20MP sensor and a mechanical shutter.The shots are faithful, without notable distortion and this even in motion, characterized by a pronounced dive and a wide dynamic range, especially in RAW.Video recording is sublime, and reaches the best of renderings in 4K@30FPS in H.265.There are also available functions such as C4K resolution or D-LOG, but not HDR video.
Dji Phantom 4 Pro V2 Plus at the best price
| Fnac marketplace | 2179,99€ | Voir l'offre |
| Darty marketplace | 2851,40€ | Voir l'offre |
| Rue Du Commerce marketplace | 2878,60€ | Voir l'offre |
| Cdiscount marketplace | 2959,55€ | Voir l'offre |
6. Dji Mavic Mini
399 € Lire le test 8Dji Mavic MiniValue for moneyLe petit rocky du droneAgile and vigorous, the Mavic Mini was able to shine in the ring and borders on undeniable victory.Despite a certain lack of smart flight modes, manual flight performance and the few quickshots can cut any competition from the same class.Ditto for the quality of the camera, which shows a remarkable level in photo as in video.Without necessarily requiring 4K, however, we expected a little more features, like an AEB mode.The interface is also quite successful and will accommodate the beginner pilots very well.If your budget allows it, do not hesitate to choose the Fly More Combo, which will greatly extend the experience and the flight time.
Le petit rocky du droneAgile and vigorous, the Mavic Mini was able to shine in the ring and borders on undeniable victory.Despite a certain lack of smart flight modes, manual flight performance and the few quickshots can cut any competition from the same class.Ditto for the quality of the camera, which shows a remarkable level in photo as in video.Without necessarily requiring 4K, however, we expected a little more features, like an AEB mode.The interface is also quite successful and will accommodate the beginner pilots very well.If your budget allows it, do not hesitate to choose the Fly More Combo, which will greatly extend the experience and the flight time.
Fruit of a long development, the Mavic Mini is kicking the leisure drone market.Announced at the end of 2019, he became the only one to offer a powerful stabilized camera and a great navigation skill for a weight below 250 gr.
Aucune alternative fiable n'existe aujourd'hui. Dans la gamme de DJI, il remplace le Spark, sans toutefois reprendre toutes ses fonctionnalités, comme le suivi des gestes. Parfait pour débuter, le bundle Fly More du Dji Mavic Mini est bien complet, avec 3 batteries et des protections d'hélices, et des fonctions simplifiées d'édition vidéo.
Without equal
The stabilization of the Mavic Mini is the most striking for its small size.Even facing the wind, the drone retains its position, and shows an incredible general maneuvering.On a rationalized interface, only the 4 basic DJI quickshots will be available but always effective.Without taking into account some benign signal losses, the flight experience is impeccable, embellished with long autonomy.
The CMOS 1/2.3 '' sensor produces a frightening image quality in 12MP, with very good sharpness and a good dynamic beach, without notable distortion, or vague.Just beware of the overexposed areas.The video quality is striking in 1080p, with beautiful natural colors, and the 2.7K@30fps offers a higher level never reached by a drone of this caliber.
Dji Mavic Mini au meilleur prix
| Darty | 399€ | Voir l'offre |
| Fnac | 399,99€ | Voir l'offre |
| Fnac marketplace | 456,38€ | Voir l'offre |
| Amazon | 492,44€ | Voir l'offre |
| Darty marketplace | 550,99€ | Voir l'offre |
| Rue Du Commerce marketplace | 551€ | Voir l'offre |
| Cdiscount marketplace | 551,99€ | Voir l'offre |
| Cdiscount marketplace | 551,99€ | Voir l'offre |
Drone: answers to all your questions
How to choose your drone?
Even with all existing navigation assistance, drone management remains a delicate exercise, requiring a period of training and assimilation of technical knowledge.Each flight presents a crash risk, which will often be fatal for the drone due to the fragility of the material.And beyond the loss of your investment, a crash can lead to damage to goods, or injure people.
What level of management do you have?
For a beginner without experience, we recommend starting small, even very small, and choosing a model that meets your needs after assimilating the basics of navigation.Once the dexterity is necessary for precise piloting is acquired, mid -range or high -end drones can be addressed more serenely.On the other hand, the concepts of audiovisual captures can be acquired on any leisure model, these all presenting automatic functions.
What is your use?
Have fun, make acrobatics, rapping or navigating in FPV ... Here, navigation capacities will take precedence over those of the camera.Drones will often be categorized according to these types of needs, and you will easily find specialized brands and models.Make beautiful photo and beautiful video ... because a aerial shooting always provides a wahou effect.The quality of the drone's camera then becomes essential, even if it means sacrificing navigation functions.
You can always improve your pilot talents, to compensate for the lack of assistance for example.But it will be more difficult to capture good shots with a mediocre camera, any good photographer you are.Note that however, the possibility of automated maneuvers can greatly facilitate the aesthetics of the capture.
What navigation capacities?
The general maneuverability, excluding assistance, of a drone can vary depending on a certain number of factors such as its weight, its generation, its size, its technological level, or the design of its radio control.You can easily assess the difficulty of controlling a device by referring to our various tests all carried out under the same conditions.
Depending on your level of apprehension, your choice can be conditioned by piloting assistance, which is characterized on a drone by its positioning, detection and obstacle avoidance system.The number of sensors dedicated to this function is very often decisive.
Also study the details of each drone to identify which types of automated maneuvers seem the most interesting and assess their efficiency and their features.Think that their numbers and qualities can evolve with updates.We can cite all smart flight modes as well as all the tracking systems of a subject.
Also and more appear by automated capture functions, for example short scripted videos and more recently hyperlapse.
Non -negligible, the autonomy of a drone will determine a fortiori in how many battery you will need to invest, which can significantly vary your investment.The flight range can also be a criterion.But this will result more by the quality of the signal and the video flow than by the distance in itself, because if we respect the legislation to the letter, a pilot must never leave his drone of the eyes.
What camera characteristics?
Because your drone is always subject to turbulence, even in the stationary state, make sure you have a good stabilization basket, the best option being on 3 mechanical axes.On 2 axes, the rest of the work will be done by the electronic stabilization of the camera, which is good but not infallible.
Highlight by manufacturers, the power of a camera is often expressed by the resolution of the photos and videos captured.However, media resolution is less crucial than the size of the sensor itself.Thus, a 13MP sensor can provide overall quality less good than a higher size 12MP sensor.It is also better to be a 1080p resolution well managed by the drone rather than a jerky and distorted 4K.The choice of resolutions will depend if not on your needs and distribution supports (TV, YouTube or Social Networks).For example, the 2.7K not being a standard TV format, it will mainly serve in edition for a cropping.
Certain advanced functions will be preferred, such as HDR, which often produces more vibrant images.Others, like D-Log, will only have their usefulness for advanced publishing.
What accessories do you need?
Inevitably, an additional battery is recommended in most cases.Even if autonomy tends to improve on drones, the lifespan of a single battery will be a brake on good flight experience and good learning, considering that there will be no recharge pointWhere you fly.Added to this is therefore the need for a charging station, and a transport bag, rarely provided in basic package.Many other accessories exist to facilitate piloting, such as a sun visor.Invest according to your emerging needs.
Finally, note that you will need a good smartphone or a tablet powerful enough to operate the control app and display the video return of the drone.
Stéphane Paput
Drones specialist
Drones specialist
Professional drone pilot and passionate about high-tech, I bring my modest contribution to the advent of one of the most innovative industries today, especially through publications of T ...
Lire d'autres articlesProfessional drone pilot and passionate about high-tech, I bring my modest contribution to the advent of one of the most innovative industries today, in particular through publications of drone tests and various missions of shotsair.
Lire d'autres articlesCet article contient des liens d'affiliation, ce qui signifie qu'une commission peut être reversée à Clubic. Les prix mentionnés sont susceptibles d'évoluer. Lirela charte de confiance
Related Articles